What Brazil´s Fire Policy Teaches Us About Policy Design
When I researched Brazil´s fire management policy, what I found was not simply an implementation failure, but a design failure from the start.
The so-called “Zero Fire Policy” remained in place throughout much of the 20th century and into the early 2000s. Brazil banned fire for decades, across all biomes and without distinction. Over time, its own ecosystems showed why that logic was flawed.
What I documented in this case is that some biomes, such as the Cerrado, depend on periodic fire to maintain their biodiversity. Suppressing fire doest not remove accumulated fuel; it allows it to build up until it eventually burns catastrophically. By 2010, massive wildfires had burned up to 91% of some protected areas in the Cerrado.
The shift took more than a decade of accumulated evidence. The first Integrated Fire Management (IFM) pilots began in 2014 in three conservation units, with results strong enough to scale. In 2024, Law 14 944 formalized the transformation: biome-specific plans, recognition of Indigenous Knowledge, and volunteer brigades with legal status.
What I find most relevant about this case for climate policy is this: a total suppression policy, applied uniformly across ecosystems with radically different ecological dynamics does not protect. On the contrary, it can slowly destroy, in ways that only become visible years later.
The question I was left with after analyzing this case is: how many conservation or land-use programs are applying the same logic - one uniform solution for contexts that are not uniform?




Comments