top of page

Why Climate Policies Fail Without Governance Analysis

Aug 15
2 min read

Before approving a climate project, most evaluators ask: does it have impact indicators? Is there a budget by activity? What is the theory of change?


The question that appears less frequently is: does the governance environment of the recipient country actually support this project — its institutions, its intersectoral coordination mechanisms, its implementation capacity — or will it slow it down once it reaches practice?


This question is not theoretical. It is exactly the type of analysis I had to do when I supported Peru’s preparation for the INC sessions — the negotiation process for the global plastics treaty.


For the negotiation documents to be useful — policy briefs, talking points, fact sheets — it was not enough to synthesize what the treaty text said. It was necessary to understand what each proposal implied for countries with very different regulatory and institutional contexts. And what that analysis constantly revealed was the gap between what an international instrument proposes and the real conditions a country needs to have in order to implement it.


Some concrete examples of what that analysis of INC documents, technical studies, and delegation positions showed:


Proposals to formalize the waste sector that assumed institutional infrastructure that many developing countries simply do not have — and that, if implemented without that base, would displace the informal workers who currently sustain real-world recycling. Financing mechanisms that required reporting and monitoring capacity that small island states do not have resources to develop without prior technical assistance.


What these patterns have in common is not bad technical design. It is that coherence analysis between what the international instrument proposes and what the national framework allows rarely forms part of the design from the beginning.


That analysis — understanding how an international mandate lands in a country’s specific environmental governance structure, who has to coordinate with whom, and what institutional capacities are missing for it to work — is exactly the work I did to prepare Peru’s interventions at the INC. And it is the type of analysis that determines whether a climate policy gets implemented or just looks good on paper.


Why most climate projects skip the governance question: assessing national capacity before implementation determines policy success or failure.Why most climate projects skip the governance question: assessing national capacity before implementation determines policy success or failure.

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn

© 2026 by Susana Paola Navas Hernández. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page